Which health plan costs less for me?
Every plan has two prices: what it costs you in a year when nothing much happens, and what it costs in a year when a lot does. Put in two plans and see both.
Example figures are filled in so you can see how it works. Replace them with yours.
How this works
The quiet-year cost is your premium for the year, less any money the employer puts into a health savings or reimbursement account. The bad-year cost adds the out-of-pocket maximum, the most you can pay for covered, in-network care in a plan year. Premiums do not count toward that maximum, which is why they are added on top.
Most years land somewhere between the two. A plan with a low premium and a high maximum wins in a quiet year and loses in a bad one, so the question is which year you can afford to have.
The match is pay you only get if you put money in yourself. If you contribute less than the match allows, the difference shows as money left with the employer.
Where the numbers come from
Take every figure from the plan documents and the Summary of Benefits and Coverage, not the enrollment screen. Use the tier you would actually elect, and check whether a family deductible is embedded or aggregate, because that changes how fast one person's bills reach the limit. Out-of-network care usually has its own, higher limits, or none.
Sources
Related guides
- What your benefits actually cost you, and the three numbers to compare
- Accrued, unlimited, use-it-or-lose-it: how time off policies differ
- The new-hire packet, annotated
An estimate for planning, not tax, legal or financial advice. Your paystub, plan documents and contract decide the real figures.